Various Sizes for Promotions
You only seem to offer one size of product for your promotions...which is frustrating. Why not offer a sliding promotion for various sizes? if someone wants a larger size than the promotion then they can pay a bit extra. That way, everyone gets in on the deal and get what they ACTUALLY want...instead of sizes they may not want to order.
How about a weekly special sampler with 2-3 comparable sized items (e.g. stickers, static clings, die cuts)
I like the promotions but they are few and far in between and it definitely helps with actually buying your products. I would be more prone to buy more products if the promotions had more than one option available.
Extend store credit expirations
" What should we work on next? Give us your insights and we'll give you a $5 credit. " I once had store credit earned from promoting stickermule on a number of occasions but it all expired. Now when i see these opportunities i no longer feel motivated to participate. Also back before my credit expired i tried to apply it to a sale but it didn't work, which made the credit feel like a "bait and switch".
I wish the promos lasted longer and that I could order a larger quantity with a discount as I often need 2-3 hundred. Otherwise, I love this company!